[jdom-interest] NullPointerException in Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value, final Namespace ns)
Rolf Lear
jdom at tuis.net
Fri Apr 6 19:08:52 PDT 2012
Hi again Gisella.
I think your examples are great, in the sense that they perfectly
illustrate the inconsistencies. On the other hand, they do not help
solve the problem of which one is right or wrong. It does make me want
to make sure that new Element(String, null) throws NPE though!
Currently the Attribute handling is 'consistent'... get, remove, set all
throw NPE for null Namespace.
I can't think of a nice way to put it, but the easiest thing to do would
be to change your code to use a conditional:
emt.setAttribute(String, String,
ns == null ? Namespace.NO_NAMESPACE : ns);
That's for 1.1.3 at least.
I still think that maybe I could change the logic on JDOM 2.0.0...
For all the get/set/remove Attribute I can maybe put the if-logic in.
Yes, I have played with it, and it's a reasonable thing to do for 2.0.0.
It is also consistent with 'new Attribute(String, String, null).
On the whole, I would agree with you, it should not throw NPE, and get
and remove should not throw NPE either.
I just changed to code to 'work', and, surprisingly, all the tests pass.
That's the wonders of wvwn with 100% code coverage you still miss some
things.
Maybe that will inspire you to try JDOM 2.0.0 ;-)
Rolf
On 06/04/2012 8:28 PM, gisella.saavedra at navis.com wrote:
> I see the inconsistencies
> I would say that when removing the nullpointerexception is OK. But when creating, you can see for example
> new Element(string name)
> new Element (String name, null)
> both set the value of Namespace to NO_NAMESPACE.
> And Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value) does not throw a NPE
> but Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value, null) does.
>
>
> -----Original Message-----
> From: Rolf Lear [mailto:jdom at tuis.net]
> Sent: Friday, April 06, 2012 4:39 PM
> To: Saavedra Gisella
> Cc: jdom-interest at jdom.org
> Subject: Re: [jdom-interest] NullPointerException in Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value, final Namespace ns)
>
> Hi Gisella
>
> Yes, I can see now where the change is. It happened between JDOM 1.0 and
> 1.1, back in 2006 ...
> https://github.com/hunterhacker/jdom/commit/b48373d95cd91986f83ac5345566258d80e88027#L0R1139
>
> In fact, this issue has been reported before:
> http://markmail.org/message/atybnwqqvlxk7ut4 and there was never any
> follow-up...
>
> So, I can see the problem, and it still exists in JDOM 2.x.
>
> But, I can't see an easy fix.
>
> I am of the opinion that null input values deserve a
> NullPointerException unless documented that nulls are allowed... but I
> also recognize that compatibility is important, and JDOM has some
> consistency in it when treating null Namespace values
> as Namespace.NO_NAMESPACE.
>
> So, I am going to think about it for a moment.... but, I would not
> expect a fix in the short term for JDOM 1.x. Even in the best
> circumstances it would take a month or so to get a 1.1.4 out...
>
> For JDOM 2.x, it is also very late in the game.... too late, in fact.
>
> In order to fix it properly I would have to decide on a strategy for
> dealing with null Namespace input. A quick 'poll' of the JDOM 2.x code
> suggests:
>
>
> Change null to NO_NAMESPACE:
> ----------------------------
> Element Constructor.
> Element.setNamespace(Namespace)
>
>
> Treats null as 'wildcard':
> --------------------------
> Element.getChild(String,Namespace)
> Element.getChildren(String,Namespace)
> Element.getChildText*(String,Namespace)
> Element.removeChild(String,Namespace)
> Element.removeChildren(String,Namespace)
>
>
> Just ignores it.
> ----------------
> Element.removeNamespaceDeclaration(Namespace)
>
>
> Throws NPE:
> -----------
> Element.addNamespaceDeclaration(Namespace)
> Element.getAttribute(String,Namespace)
> Element.getAttributeValue(String,Namespace);
> Element.getAttributeValue(String,Namespace, String);
> Element.removeAttribute(String,Namespace);
> Element.setAttribute(String,String,Namespace)
>
>
> I think, having looked at the 'poll' results, when it comes to
> Attributes, the NPE is the 'right' thing.
>
> Given that getAttribute(String,Namespace) throws NPE (and
> removeAttribute), and they have 'always' thrown NPE, I think it is
> logical that setAttribute(String,String,Namespace) throws NPE too.
>
> Bottom line is that I am not convinced that it is a bug in 1.1.3.
> Perhaps it was a bug in 1.0 to allow the null.
>
> So, this all comes around to the 'push-back' option. How difficult is it
> for you to do the null-check yourself before you call setAttribute()?
>
> That is the obvious workaround, and it is the 'right thing'....
>
> Rolf
>
>
>
>
> On 06/04/2012 5:53 PM, gisella.saavedra at navis.com wrote:
>> the stack trace belongs to JDOM 1.1.3
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Saavedra Gisella
>> Sent: Friday, April 06, 2012 2:49 PM
>> To: 'Rolf Lear'
>> Cc: jdom-interest at jdom.org
>> Subject: RE: [jdom-interest] NullPointerException in Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value, final Namespace ns)
>>
>> Rolf,
>>
>> I believe you might be looking at the wrong method:
>>
>> This is JDOM 1.0 (ns is passed as null)
>>
>> public Element setAttribute(String name, String value, Namespace ns) {
>> return setAttribute(new Attribute(name, value, ns));
>> }
>>
>> Inside this code, the constructor new Attribute(name, value, ns) calls:
>>
>> public Attribute(String name, String value, Namespace namespace) {
>> setName(name);
>> setValue(value);
>> setNamespace(namespace);
>> }
>>
>> Here setNamespace(namespace) calls:
>> public Attribute setNamespace(Namespace namespace) {
>> if (namespace == null) {
>> namespace = Namespace.NO_NAMESPACE;
>> }
>>
>> // Verify the attribute isn't trying to be in a default namespace
>> // Attributes can't be in a default namespace
>> if (namespace != Namespace.NO_NAMESPACE&&
>> namespace.getPrefix().equals("")) {
>> throw new IllegalNameException("", "attribute namespace",
>> "An attribute namespace without a prefix can only be the " +
>> "NO_NAMESPACE namespace");
>> }
>> this.namespace = namespace;
>> return this;
>> }
>>
>> where namespace being null is set to NO_NAMESPACE.
>>
>>
>>
>>
>> Stack trace (JODM 1.1.3):
>>
>> java.lang.NullPointerException
>> at org.jdom.AttributeList.indexOf(AttributeList.java:378)
>> at org.jdom.AttributeList.get(AttributeList.java:366)
>> at org.jdom.Element.getAttribute(Element.java:1004)
>> at org.jdom.Element.setAttribute(Element.java:1178)
>> at com.navis.argo.business.snx.AbstractXmlExporter.setAttribute(AbstractXmlExporter.java:40)
>>
>>
>> --------------
>>
>>
>> -----Original Message-----
>> From: Rolf Lear [mailto:jdom at tuis.net]
>> Sent: Friday, April 06, 2012 2:40 PM
>> To: Saavedra Gisella
>> Cc: jdom-interest at jdom.org
>> Subject: Re: [jdom-interest] NullPointerException in Element.setAttribute(final String name, final String value, final Namespace ns)
>>
>> Hi Gisella.
>>
>> I have looked through the JDOM 1.0 code. JDOM 1.0 was released in
>> September 2004. Here's the code as it was at the time:
>>
>> Here's the getAttribute method:
>> https://github.com/hunterhacker/jdom/blob/jdom-1.0/core/src/java/org/jdom/Element.java#L980
>>
>> Here's the attributes.get(String,Namespace) method:
>> https://github.com/hunterhacker/jdom/blob/jdom-1.0/core/src/java/org/jdom/AttributeList.java#L365
>>
>> And that calls the indexOf(String,Namespace) method:
>> https://github.com/hunterhacker/jdom/blob/jdom-1.0/core/src/java/org/jdom/AttributeList.java#L377
>>
>> Which calls namespace.getURI().
>>
>> The way I see it is that JDOM 1.0 would always throw a
>> NullPointerException if you gave it a null Namespace.
>>
>> I don't think it would have ever worked in JDOM 1.0...
>>
>> Did you have your own custom build of JDOM 1.0?
>>
>> Rolf
>>
>> On 06/04/2012 5:08 PM, Rolf Lear wrote:
>>> Hi Gisella.
>>>
>>> Is it possible to send us a stack trace, at least the parts including
>>> the org.jdom.* code.
>>>
>>> Thanks
>>>
>>> Rolf
>>>
>>>
>>> On 06/04/2012 1:43 PM, gisella.saavedra at navis.com wrote:
>>>> I just upgraded from jdom 1.0 to jdom 1.1.3
>>>>
>>>> and I was setting an attribute where the namespace was NULL.
>>>>
>>>> The old code was different, it was NOT calling get(...), so it was setting
>>>> the namespace to namespace.NO_NAMESPACE when the namespace was NULL,
>>>>
>>>> before calling this get(...)
>>>>
>>>> but the new code, when it calls getAttribute(name, ns) (first line of
>>>> method described)
>>>>
>>>> is getting a null pointer on the namespace.
>>>>
>>>> Probably the namespace needs to be set to NO_NAMESPACE before calling
>>>> get(..) when it is NULL.
>>>>
>>>> *Gisella Saavedra**
>>>> *Framework Team
>>>> _gsaavedra at navis.com<mailto:gsaavedra at navis.com>_
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> http://www.navis.com/images/spacer.gif
>>>>
>>>> 1000 Broadway, Suite 150, Oakland, CA 94607 | T+1 510 267 5123 T Main+1
>>>> 510 267 5000 F+1 510 267 5100 | _http://www.navis.com
>>>> <http://www.navis.com/>_
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>
>>>> _______________________________________________
>>>> To control your jdom-interest membership:
>>>> http://www.jdom.org/mailman/options/jdom-interest/youraddr@yourhost.com
>>>
>>> _______________________________________________
>>> To control your jdom-interest membership:
>>> http://www.jdom.org/mailman/options/jdom-interest/youraddr@yourhost.com
>>>
>>
>
More information about the jdom-interest
mailing list